As it approaches its 100th anniversary, the American Arbitration Association (AAA) is embracing innovation rather than tradition. Long recognised as a global leader in alternative dispute resolution, the AAA plans to launch its first AI-powered arbitrator in November, marking a major step in integrating artificial intelligence into legal processes.
AI Arbitrator Overview
The AI arbitrator will initially handle documents-only construction disputes, an area known for high case volume and the need for efficiency. The system will analyse submissions, assess case merits, and produce draft awards, which will then be reviewed and approved by human arbitrators before being finalised. According to Bridget Mary McCormack, AAA’s President and CEO, this innovation could reduce arbitration costs by 30–50% and shorten resolution times by 25–30%, with further gains expected as the technology matures.
The AAA also plans to extend the technology to insurance disputes, particularly payer–provider cases, which similarly involve numerous lower-value claims.
Development and Training
Developed in collaboration with QuantumBlack, AI by McKinsey, the AI system was trained on over 1,500 real construction case awards from AAA’s archives. These were chosen because construction decisions typically include detailed reasoning, enabling the AI to learn how human arbitrators analyse evidence and apply legal principles. Over 1,000 simulated test cases were run, involving arbitrators, lawyers, and law students to ensure reliability before live deployment.
Human-in-the-Loop Model
A cornerstone of the system is its human-in-the-loop design. The AI first deconstructs parties’ submissions, identifying claims, evidence, and legal issues, then returns this analysis for validation. Parties can confirm or correct the AI’s understanding, ensuring transparency and accuracy before a draft award is prepared. A human arbitrator then reviews the AI’s draft, supported by an advanced “co-pilot” interface featuring case summaries, timelines, and clickable evidence. The arbitrator makes final edits, signs the award, and their feedback continuously improves the AI model.
Efficiency and Access to Justice
Testing showed that arbitrators reviewed case materials 30–50% faster with the AI assistant while maintaining decision quality. By reducing time and cost, the AAA anticipates the technology could expand access to arbitration, potentially increasing annual dispute resolutions tenfold. McCormack emphasised that lower costs and simpler processes could open arbitration to individuals and small businesses previously excluded by expense and complexity.
Impact on Arbitrators
While some may fear automation, McCormack insists that AI will augment, not replace, human arbitrators. Those who adapt to AI-integrated workflows will remain essential, as technology will create more cases and career opportunities rather than fewer. However, she cautioned that arbitrators unwilling to adapt “may need to consider what the next phase of life looks like.”
Innovation Legacy
This initiative is part of the AAA’s wider generative AI strategy, which already includes chatbots, document summarisation tools, and AI-enhanced case management systems. As the AAA approaches its centenary, McCormack likened the introduction of AI arbitration to the original innovation of arbitration itself a century ago—expanding access to justice.
“Arbitration was created to make dispute resolution more accessible,” she said. “Now, AI lets us deliver on that promise for the modern world.”
Source: LawSites
Leave a Reply